15/11/2012 01:39 | By Dan Owen, contributor, MSN TV

TV review: The Hour series two's promising start

Reviewed: Series two of newsroom drama The Hour, starring Ben Whishaw and Dominic West, aired on BBC2.

Romola Garai and Ben Whishaw (© Romola Garai and Ben Whishaw. Image BBC)


The Hour, BBC2's newsroom drama from writer-producer Abi Morgan, returns for a second series of six episodes, with the action having moved on a year to November 1957.


The production values appear to have been boosted, meaning The Hour's lost its BBC Four-style minimalist feel. The sets, fashions and camerawork all feel improved, rivalling slick US counterparts to an extent..


The series appears to be using overused plot ideas: like the dutiful wife who knows her husband's playing away, and the beautiful Soho showgirl being abused by her criminal bosses.

Full review

I wasn't a big fan of The Hour's first series because it felt like half a promising show needlessly complicated by a silly espionage subplot (much like BBC2's cancelled US import, Pan Am).

Maybe Abi Morgan wanted to differentiate it from Mad Men that way, but it didn't work; critics were still compelled to compare it to the US Emmy-winner, even if it more accurately resembled the 1976 movie Network.

Considering this episode had to reacquaint viewers to all the characters, explain the changes in their lives, while introducing newcomers and outlining fresh storylines, it did a very capable job.

"I wasn't a big fan of The Hour's first series."

We are now in 1957 and The Hour has become a ratings smash, inspiring imitators; its anchorman Hector Madden (played by The Wire's Dominic West) is enjoying his resulting celebrity status, while tempted by offers to defect to ITV.

Bel Rowley (Romola Garai) is trying to run the show all by herself; the BBC has a new Head of News in the unyielding Randall Brown (The Thick Of It's Peter Capaldi) who plans changes like giving egotistical Hector a co-host.

Meanwhile, prodigious Freddie Lyon (Ben Whishaw) has returned from America with a trendy beard, reinvigorated perspective, and a sexy girlfriend.

The Hour improves

Away from the character's lives, the big concerns for series two feel more varied than last year's fixation on the Suez Canal Crisis (which was a dry topic).

This time we have the more enticing prospect of the government siphoning budget away from policing and into nuclear defences in the wake of Sputnik 2's launch.

Bel wants to focus the public's attention on the growing criminal underworld - exemplified by suave gangster Raphael Cilenti (Vincent Riotta), owner of the El Paradis club Hector frequents in London's Soho.

What's pleasing about series two already is seeing a focus on its strengths; the politics of BBC newsgathering in the 1950s (where people believe the introduction of post codes is Orwellian), and the central triptych's love-hate relationship.

I particularly enjoy seeing Whishaw and Garai perform together, and it should be even more fun now Freddie has found love while he was gone.

Vote now!
An error occurred while trying to display the data. Please try again later.

Did The Hour live up to all the hype?

Thanks for being one of the first people to vote. Results will be available soon. Check for results

  1. 79 %
    Yes - it's very good
    64 votes
    21 %
    No - it's overrated
    17 votes

Total Responses: 81
Not scientifically valid. Results are updated every minute.

There's nothing in The Hour that hasn't been done countless times, but the actors are extremely watchable. Whishaw is becoming a genuine Hollywood star, with roles in Skyfall (as Q) and Cloud Atlas; his association with the former is especially amusing here as Freddie always jokingly refers to Bel as "Moneypenny".

This opening episode popped off the screen to a greater degree than previous efforts; it looked more assured and the scope of the world felt widened (due to a bigger budget, or better use of finances).

Throw in the likes of Peter Capaldi joining established supporting actors like Anna Chancellor, and The Hour reeks of class.

There were storytelling issues last year, and a script that was, at times, peppered with anachronisms, but the appealing return of this premiere suggests they've taken note of what worked.

It's a slow-burn so it probably won't appeal to many viewers, but if you're craving sophisticated drama, The Hour is a safe bet.

  • Verdict: Abi Morgan's writing to her strengths and the result is enthralling.

    Star grade

What other reviews say

The Guardian - "It's still not entirely clear if The Hour really knows exactly what it wants to be."

On The Box - "It's a British Mad Men rip-off that now has Peter Capaldi in it. And that makes it great."

What people on Twitter said

@JohnhampsonUK - "Slow start but #thehour is picking up now."

@TVAlisonGraham (Alison Graham of the Radio Times) - "I think it's passionless and insufferably in love with itself, but others adore it."

The views in this article are those of the author alone and not of MSN or Microsoft

Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

latest tv videos

Get the Bing News App for Windows 8 (© Microsoft)

latest tv news