Harry Hill's X Factor spoof 'I Can't Sing' arrives in the West End next year, and here are the moments from the show we hope feature.
01/09/2012 21:43 | By MSN editors, editor, MSN Entertainment
X Factor 2012: Mel B in 'nice judge' shocker!
Mel B - week three
1 of 28
Share this Gallery
Gary Barlow, Louis Walsh, Nicole Scherzinger and Tulisa Contostavlos may be the permanent X Factor judges, but in the third week of the series, the talk is still all about Spice Girl, Melanie Brown.
The X Factor juggernaut rolled into Manchester and Glasgow. Mel B, the guest judge in Manchester, was on her best behaviour in this instalment, especially compared to the first episode in which she'd slated practically every act.
However, posters on forums and social networking sites love her - whether she's good or bad. A tweet from the Daily Star's James Ingham was typical of the view on Twitter: "Loving @OfficialMelB on tonight's @TheXFactor again. Such a good judge! Classic put down to one deluded mum! #xfactor"
Many fans are now wondering why she wasn't offered the judging chair following the departure of Kelly Rowland. So how did the rest of the night pan out? Find out in this gallery.
related stories on msn
81Comments
02/09/2012 07:14
She is honest, she says it like we all want to say it.
02/09/2012 07:10
shes class... and about time we had an honest judge..x
02/09/2012 09:18
Mel B is better then all the female judges, she knows who should be singing in the next round, not some of the rubbish the other judges pick, Mel B should be permanent judge, lets see more people singing on the stage, we want more show on the stage, then looking at the judges doing there make ups and eating, very poor show on the stage, only one song and then add comes up, lets see more and more people performing, then to see the lousy judges making a puffy make up,
02/09/2012 11:19
Cant stand Mel B......get her off our screens. Shes got no talent so how can she judge a talent show......jeeeez
02/09/2012 11:58
Mel B a judge? lmfao, she sounds like a pet shop on fire herself so how can she judge others on singing...then again it is the xfactor :s an awful karaoke competition :P
02/09/2012 10:26
No no please get her off our screens, she is a has been with no career since the Spice Girls except for parading her love life, but has the cheek to criticise up and coming singers, some of which have more talent than she will ever have.
02/09/2012 18:15
Excuse me for my ignorance, Antony Jones, but what is a soot sack. I hope it's not some childish reference to her skin colour. I think she is blunt and to the point. it may upset some disolusioned people but if you're crap, you're crap. Anyway. if the comment about soot sack is reference to her skin colour, at least have the courage of your convictions and put a pic of your face on your comment so we can see what a real pig you are
02/09/2012 07:46
MEL B IS GREAT AT THIS - IT'S RIGHT UP HER STREET AND SHE HAS SOOO MUCH MORE PERSONALITY AND REALNESS THAN THE OTHER TWO FEMALE JUDGES: WHATSHERNAME! AND WOTNOT!!
MAKE MEL B A PERMANENT JUDGE AND GET RID OF ONE, NO TWO, OF THE OTHERS. THAT WOULD WORK FOR ME!:-)
02/09/2012 13:10
More Mel B?
You have got to be **** joking!! The woman is rude and arrogant.So she was a Spice Girl.So what? A manufactured group,low on talent but "marketable"Get rid!!!
02/09/2012 14:29
Best quips!
You look like a pop star..... you don't sound like a pop star!
Brilliant.
Can we do another song.
Nawhh
02/09/2012 12:12
Another waste of space, just like many others that are talentless cr@p like Cole Gaga Madonna, Barlow and porn star Rihanna
02/09/2012 10:04
She looks white.
02/09/2012 15:11
cheap tv nice gimmick.hang em all
02/09/2012 09:25
Melanie was good,but so were a lot of contestants this week,this year seems like its going to get tougher to decide who has the x factor!
02/09/2012 09:50
Tell it like it is Mel, too many time wasters on the show as it is, maybe they will think twice now.
02/09/2012 14:22
Neree Mckenzie
She had several hit singles,so hardly flopped.
Do you think that nobody is entitled to give negative views on contestants unless they're
good singers themselves? If so,then the great majority of us aren't entitled to do so
either.
Neither Simon Cowell or Louis Walsh should have ever been judges going by your
argument.
She had several hit singles,so hardly flopped.
Do you think that nobody is entitled to give negative views on contestants unless they're
good singers themselves? If so,then the great majority of us aren't entitled to do so
either.
Neither Simon Cowell or Louis Walsh should have ever been judges going by your
argument.
02/09/2012 09:54
mel b needs to pull her neck in what gives her the right to judge a singer, she cant sing herself unless she is supported by a group , and even then its only one liners go away and learn some manners
02/09/2012 12:42
I don't know how she has the cheek to comment on the singing ability of anybody when she can't sing herself
02/09/2012 10:53
lm sorry but in the "would you?" stakes, Tulisa makes Mel look grim!
02/09/2012 12:45
Brute honesty is what the show needs. Keep those awful people with stars in their eyes from auditioning, pulling the show down. Simon can't sing and he's a judge. At least Mel has some knowledge of the business. Get rid of Nicole.
Report
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
latest tv videos
The Hangover III: Ken Jeong praises co-stars
American comedian Ken Jeong praises co-stars Bradley Cooper and Zach Galifianakis while promoting his latest movie, The Hangover III.
Date 18 mins ago, Duration 4:39, Views 0
Video by: ITN
-
The Hangover III: Ken Jeong praises co-stars
Date 18 mins ago 4:39Tooltip Information:
The Hangover III: Ken Jeong praises co-starsVideo by:Description: American comedian Ken Jeong praises co-stars Bradley Cooper and Zach Galifianakis while promoting his latest movie, The Hangover III.Rating: 4Views: 0
-
The Hangover Part III premiere: Ken 'Chow' Jeong interview
Date 11 hrs ago 2:02Tooltip Information:
The Hangover Part III premiere: Ken 'Chow' Jeong interviewVideo by:Description: Ken Jeong talks about playing Mr. Chow in The Hangover movies at the Part III premiere in London.Rating: 4Views: 34
-
The Hangover Part III premiere in Los Angeles
Date 21/05/13 1:29Tooltip Information:
The Hangover Part III premiere in Los AngelesVideo by:Description: Stars of The Hangover Part III gather on the red carpet to close out the popular film franchise at the premiere in Los Angeles.Rating: 4Views: 124
-
The Hangover Part III premiere: Zach Galifianakis interview
Date 12 hrs ago 1:31Tooltip Information:
The Hangover Part III premiere: Zach Galifianakis interviewVideo by:Description: Zach Galifianakis speaking on the red carpet at the UK premiere of The Hangover Part III in London.Rating: 4Views: 28
latest tv news
The Only Way Is Essex cast, including Joey Essex and Sam Faiers, have landed in Marbella for their annual holiday.
Mick McManus, who entertained millions every Saturday on World of Sport, was one of several British wrestlers who found fame in the ring.
Michelle Collins is excited about her Corrie alter-ego's wedding
As Corrie pub landlady Stella, Michelle Collins is always centre of the action
Debbie Rush and Ian Puleston-Davies play a couple in Coronation Street
Shane Richie is looking forward to working with Samantha Womack again
The TOWIE crew could be competing for viewers against a new Brixton-based reality show
Katheryn Winnick stars in new web series Vikings
Damian Lewis has been nominated for best actor at the Critic's Choice TV awards in the US
This year's Big Brother housemates must grow their own food
Joey Essex is said to have agreed to stay in TOWIE for fiancee Sam Faiers
