Jack Kibble-White
Updated: 13/01/2012 16:20 | By Jack Kibble-White, columnist, MSN TV

Is Miranda Hart the new queen of TV?

Miranda Hart seems to be taking over TV. Jack Kibble-White explores why telly just can’t seem to get enough of her.


Miranda Hart (© BBC)

Miranda Hart

The BBC's adaptation of Call The Midwife starts on 15 January. This 1950s drama about an order of nursing nuns is just the kind of thing for Sunday evening TV, combining a solid story with a touch of popular nostalgia.

However to some, the series' casting has offered up a bit of a surprise; comedy actress Miranda Hart is playing one of the midwives.

"Comedy will always be my first passion," Ms Hart recently told reporters, "but absolutely I think it will be amazing if I could have a career in which I could do both."

While it is unusual for a comedy actor take on a serious role, it is not without precedent. Over the years, we've seen some spectacular examples where such imaginative casting has paid dividends. Hugh Laurie in House, for instance, is probably the premier example.

Let's not forget Catherine Tate in Doctor Who (her success as Donna Noble is particularly laudable given how many sceptical Who fans she won over in the process).

Mind you, there are also those comedic casting experiments that have proven less successful. I for one was never convinced by Eddie Izzard's performance in US drama The Riches. Similarly, Mark Gatiss - a brilliant scriptwriter and comic actor - is just too hammy for my liking in his role as Mycroft in the otherwise exceptional Sherlock.

Miranda Hart for Doctor Who?

Yet while some might question whether Miranda really is the right choice for a serious bit of BBC telly, I think there is a bigger question which is being overlooked: why is Miranda Hart connected with pretty much any television series that's currently in production?

"why is Miranda Hart connected with pretty much any television series that's currently in production?"

When Alesha Dixon announced her departure from Strictly Come Dancing, the press were quick to suggest Miranda was being lined up as a "left-field" replacement.

We were told the show's producers were looking for someone "really startling" to join Len Goodman, Craig Revel Horwood and Bruno Tonioli on the judging panel; apparently Miranda fit the bill.

Well, given she knows nothing about dancing, such an addition would indeed be "startling", although perhaps not for the reasons envisaged.

Happily, Miranda seems to have scotched that rumour. But, like a television hydra, chop down one rumour and another two will grow back in its place.

So next, we heard that Miranda was being lined up to appear alongside Amanda Holden on Britain's Got Talent; as ex-judge Michael McIntyre proved, a comedian on the Britain's Got Talent panel is no bad thing. However, ITV finally confirmed Alesha Dixon and David Walliams as the new faces. No Miranda.

"she's going to pop up in Doctor Who"

If you believe the latest chatter, she's going to pop up in Doctor Who. Do we really want Miranda accompanying the Doctor on his travels once Amy and Rory depart (as they are scheduled to do over the course of the next series)?

And it's not just future telly projects. Over Christmas, Miranda turned up on such disparate shows as The BBC Sports Personality of the Year, The Big Fat Quiz of The Year, Michael McIntyre's Comedy Roadshow and Wild Weekend with Miranda (which saw her trek across the Alps with all-action man Bear Grylls).

Why is Miranda so hot at the moment? Her eponymously titled sitcom is an entertaining enough show, and the lady herself never comes across as anything less than likeable, but how has she come to dominate the schedules in this way?

Television is a strange beast and it is seldom possible to get to the bottom of exactly why certain talents suddenly become "hot" while others remain decidedly "not".

Take John Barrowman. Back in 2005, he was an accomplished song and dance man, but his television profile - beyond an aborted stint as a Saturday morning children's presenter - was pretty much non-existent.

It took just a single guest appearance in Doctor Who for the cheesy, but loveable, all-round entertainer to find himself in huge demand for pretty much any show going.

And to prove once and for all that the vagaries of TV are completely unfathomable, for a spell back in 1987, awful impressionist and old-school comedian Les Dennis could regularly be seen on BBC1 and ITV on a Saturday night - at the same time!

The ubiquitous Miranda Hart

In truth, I suspect certain celebs become hot property due to a media version of The Emperor's New Clothes. As soon as Miranda started to notch up the odd guest appearance, other programme makers probably began to wonder why she wasn't appearing on their show and took steps to remedy that situation.

Thus the cycle begins anew, with more TV bods spotting Miranda on more shows and so hiring her to appear on theirs.

This, of course, culminates with the inevitable point somewhere down the line, where those self-same programme makers decide en masse that Miranda's over-exposed and drop her like a hot potato.

This might not be good news for her, but it's great news for the phalanx of likeable enough comedy actors denied a spot on a panel show, or a cameo in a sitcom, because Miranda's already bagged it.

If you're convinced Miranda Hart's ubiquitousness is here to stay, seek out the opinion of poor old ex-flavour of the month Les Dennis and he will put you right - assuming you can track down exactly where he is, of course.

In the meantime, if you're a Miranda Hart fan - you've never had it so good. Let's see if she can successfully make the move into dramatic roles. And if she does, she will fully deserve her accolade as the queen of British TV.

68Comments
13/03/2012 23:25
avatar
I  agree with most on this  and do not find her funny at all.as for the person saying give her a chance she has a quite a lot of chances to make me laugh (how long does it take) as for the person comparing reality shows with her don't know where your coming from completely different viewing.I don't watch towie or bb i'm a celeb and never would it's crap t.v just the same as miranda.she is not funny and hate to watch her not so funny face pulling that she does .I have a good sense of humour and laugh at most comedians and their shows but she is just a turnover channel for me.
19/02/2012 23:30
avatar
Think she is brilliant in Call the Midwife
10/02/2012 05:01
avatar
No she is not. Pretty talentless methinks ,but a PC goldmine. A LARGE woman on our screens to placate the LARGE women of society who feel they are not being represented on tv.
16/01/2012 23:41
avatar

 If its not Miranda its flippin Sarah Milicant........dozy geordie bird with the same 3 "funny stories" 5 times a week or Miranda, posh bird who falls over a bit....5 times a week....

 Of course it always helps on British TV to have a nice double barrel name ( Hart-****...) and a fee paying boarding school education. Just wiki Downe house School and see hwo many other gells from her time are on TV or married to royalty.....middle class my arse, if she had been born actually as a man (not just looking like one) she'd just be another old etonian like 2 thirds of the working actors in this country (pm included).

15/01/2012 23:41
avatar
Well im 22 but Think shes Aimed at all ages, and its nice to have comedy out their that isnt rude or vulga for the kids,  She is just one of those Clumbsy Daft Anties Evryone Has, and i love it when she knows shes said something embarassing and the camra zooms on her face when she pulls that awkword moment look.

Such Fun!!!

avatar
It must be middle class women's sense of humour. I heard her radio show too it was crap. And I've seen her on talk shows she was out her depth trying to ad lib. Her whole career reminds me of the emperors new clothes. She must worry that one day she will be found out.
avatar
Third rate comedian on a good day and my mum likes her, just about sums it all up. Utterly disgraceful to British comedy, its slapstick gone wrong. Try and compare our comedy these days to Fawlty towers or Black Adder and you'd be lost for ideas.
15/01/2012 21:59
avatar

Miranda sucks donkey balls and actually the donkey is the funnier of the two.....

15/01/2012 21:58
avatar
Please no not more miranda, she just isnt funny. She fails on the simple point of acting, if you cant act you cannot deliver comedy.....im not alone my parents find the same thing (which was odd as they loved gavin and stacey!). 
I Just hate her radio take overs too, on radio 2 its just switch off radio.....sorry would love to like another talented female comic......sorry BBC....
15/01/2012 21:18
avatar
Ken Innes... thank you for sharing your knowledge of English and Latin.... but this is a social networking site and not Open bl00dy University. We didnt all get a degree in advanced smartarsedness.... so log on to cleverdicks.com and impress them.... Anyway I know Latin... or at least I did the last time I updated my Curriculum Vitae !!
avatar
I see nothing funny in this woman at all; best of luck to those who do!
15/01/2012 20:26
avatar
Probably the license money the BBC are going to spend trying to force feed this not very funny women on an indifferent public could go to save a few local radio stations which are under serious threat of closure. It's as if they've decided we must learn to appreciate her when in reality she might have passed as a minor support character in the old days when they used to have talented people making top comedies. Today they're not cutting the mustard.
15/01/2012 19:58
avatar
I think she did a stint on Radio 2 with some other person who I've never heard of and it was the most boring thing I've ever had to listen to.  She must have the most boring voice and she's not funny!!  What is so interesting about her the BBC must be desperate. 
avatar

No Ken, she doesn't find me funny, but I'm not earning money as a comedian, please feel free to pull me up on my spelling any time you like, its hilarious

15/01/2012 19:40
avatar
Kelly, do you mean "herbivorous" rather than "herbivore"?  I don't suppose that she thinks that you're funny either. 
15/01/2012 18:56
avatar
First of all, humour is subjective.  What one person finds hilarious can mean nothing to someone else (and vice versa).  I personally find her to be an intelligent witty lady who can be funny or act in a serious vein.  It's nice to see someone on tv who doesn't conform to what people perceive as an attractive lady.  Check out Sarah Millican for another example.  I'd rather be in the company of someone like these ladies than any of the brainless talentless bimbos who populate such programmes as BB, TOWIE, X factor ad nauseum.
15/01/2012 18:40
avatar

i dont get how shes funny, ive seen a few episodes of miranda, and i hardly laugh in them, i laughed once through one whole episode, only because someone fell over...

avatar
She reminds me of some kind of big herbivore creature and I don't think she is funny
avatar
To many people in this country,  LACK ANY SENSE OF HUMOUR!!!!
   I thought her corny at first  BUT  ---  She grows on you & I love the way she seriously addresses the audience in her comedy show!!!

Give her a chance.  She is great fun.!!!

BRITS, TRY TO  LEARN  LAUGHING AT GOOD CLEAN FUN!! Smile
avatar
Typical BBC, Wasting public money again,Its not what you know its who you know !!
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Scroll upScroll down

latest tv videos

msn tv poll

How do you feel about Anthony Moon leaving EastEnders?

Thanks for being one of the first people to vote. Results will be available soon. Check for results

  1. 69 %
    Glad - he's boring
    2,165 votes
  2.  
    31 %
    Sad - he's great
    979 votes

Total Responses: 3,144
Not scientifically valid. Results are updated every minute.