14/02/2012 10:11 | By Emma Roberts, Entertainment reporter, MSN Entertainment

Upstairs Downstairs returns

The second series of the BBC's revival of Upstairs Downstairs returns to our screens this month – but, does it have what it takes to steal the period drama crown from Downton?


There's no question that Downton Abbey has made period dramas exciting again - it's one of ITV's most popular shows and has even enjoyed success in the States, which is nigh impossible for UK shows these days.

Will the second series of Upstairs Downstairs be as good as Downton Abbey? (© BBC ITV)

Will the second series of Upstairs Downstairs be as good as Downton Abbey?


But, it's commonly known that Downton Abbey wasn't the first period drama to cause a stir - back in 1971, the BBC launched Upstairs Downstairs, a show which enjoyed wide-spread success, due to its intriguing cast and explosively scandalous plot lines.

And now, two years after the BBC revived Upstairs Downstairs with three 90 minute, action-packed episodes, the show is back for a second series, this time spanning over six episodes.

With a longer series and a stellar cast, does Upstairs Downstairs now have what it takes to steal the period drama throne from Downton Abbey?

The first series of the BBC's revival of Upstairs Downstairs followed the lives of the residents of Eaton Place, as they struggled through the 1930s Depression era in England and the second series looks like it's going to be as dramatic as ever, as some saucy plot lines have already been revealed.

Seeing double: Lady Agnes Holland, left, looks similar to Downton's Lady Mary Crawley (© ITV and BBC)

Seeing double: Lady Agnes Holland, left, looks similar to Downton's Lady Mary Crawley


This series, Emilia Fox will guest star as Lady Portia Alresford, who becomes the secret lesbian lover of Dr Blanche Mottershead - so far, so scandalous!

In an interview with The Mirror, one of the show's writers Heidi Thomas said about the romance:

"These are two brilllant, intellectual women who have a deeply romantic friendship in the tradition of the great Edwardian romantics, which gives each of them endless stimulation and satisfaction."

This time, the series follows the residents of Eaton Place, as they live through the Second World War. And, as well as Lady Portia Alresford, we also meet some other new characters, including the feisty and beautiful maid Beryl, who's played by Laura Haddock. She looks like she's going to be a bit of a trouble maker!

Trouble maker: New maid Beryl, played by Laura Haddock.

Trouble maker: New maid Beryl, played by Laura Haddock.


What's more, Sir Hallam's (Ed Stoppard) preoccupation with burgeoning Nazi Germany leads him into dangerous waters - we hope he doesn't end up going to war - what would his partner, Lady Agnes Holland (Keeley Hawes) say?

An error occurred while trying to display the data. Please try again later.

Which do you prefer?

Thanks for being one of the first people to vote. Results will be available soon. Check for results

  1.  
    10 %
    The new Upstairs Downstairs
    123 votes
  2.  
    24 %
    The original Upstairs Downstairs
    298 votes
  3. 66 %
    Downton Abbey
    804 votes

Total Responses: 1,225
Not scientifically valid. Results are updated every minute.


Have a flick through the gallery below to see new pictures from the second series of Upstairs Downstairs, which starts Sunday 19 February on BBC One.

1 of 16
Pictures from the second series of Upstairs Downstairs
19Comments
20/02/2012 18:11
avatar
Watched a bit of Upstairs Downstairs last night......................Thought it was all a bit silly really.  Not a patch on the original version and also not up to the standard of Downton Abbey. I would say, however, that the modern trend for "on location" filming of most current Drama Series, whilst very "realistic", does nothing for sound quality, even with all the clever "gismo's" on a lot of modern TV's.  
16/02/2012 13:06
avatar

To me, this sounds like two quality programmes which are actually going to be worth watching and I shall be watching both of them as a  welcome relief from the diet of total rubbish such as soap operas and reality TV .  Brilliant stuff both period dramas .

 

 

avatar

I am at a loss to understand as to why we are being wound up to prefer one to the other. And people are daft enough to fall for it.

 

It's like that huge debacle that occurs all over the nation every Saturday afternoon in football grounds. Slavish, blinkered loyalty following of one thing and blindly denouncing the other.

 

 I shall watch and enjoy both; if they are not on at the same time . And if they are,  I shall watch one on iplayer and  STILL  enjoy BOTH. It's only a TV show when all is said and done.

15/02/2012 16:56
avatar

 why are we paying for a licence........

 

why is a good question with the amount of advertising there is on the bbc plus the amount of utter crap they show like homes under the hammer wanted down under casualty and deadenders to name but a few among many.

15/02/2012 03:34
avatar
All three series are excellent. The writing, direction and attention to detail is great. They each depict Great Britain in a different historical period and/or different strata of British society. I do not think one has to be the winner and agree there is room for all 3. The original Upstairs Downstairs relied on acting and was more theatrical and there was less in the way of scenery. Both Downton Abbey and the New Upstairs Downstairs are more like films. The sets are bigger and there is a soundtrack. The acting is quite strong in both series and they tell different stories and are educational. So I enjoy them all.
15/02/2012 00:28
avatar
Downton Abbey gets my vote every time, great entertainment. Hope to see more. Beats some of the crap that is shown on telly these days. ie Celebrity Big Brother. Come Dancing. etc.
14/02/2012 23:51
avatar
am i the only 1 who didn't realise there was a revival of upsatirs downstairs?!
i'm going with downton purely for the fact that i haven't seen the first series of upstairs! howeva if available on bbc player i'm open to it!
however i agree theres so much **** on tv nowadays tv licence is just daylight robbery! half the stuff you watch on tv u can watch online WITHOUT ADVERTS so why are we paying for a licence..........cause we're idiots thats why! :-/
14/02/2012 23:26
avatar
Downton is a right load of old c*bblers!  The storylines are so obvious a five year old could write them and the toffs are all so thoroughly decent to their minions - it is totally, totally unreal.  The little action there is is all below stairs but even that is so mild you could feed it to a baby.  It should really be on at three o'clock in the afternoon, the graveyard of second-rate drama.  I watched Upstairs Downstairs and was captivated by it at the time, I doubt I would be now and the new version is not going to be better drama, it is just going to be sensational to pull in veiwers.  The only decent telly these days are wildlife programmes and you can only watch so much of that - why have we got more than four channels?  We can barely fill those!
14/02/2012 23:01
avatar

We shall watch with interest. One thing's for sure - We won't have all of those damned adverts to contend with!

 

which channel do you watch that has no adverts then certainly not the bbc.

14/02/2012 22:46
avatar
I would have thought that Upstairs Downstairs has run its course.  In the 1940's houses with servants were a rarity and certainly when the war came anyone still in service would have joined one of the war professions.
14/02/2012 22:42
avatar

Is this all the bbc can do these days, bring out their own version of popular shows running on itv?  You have to wonder what we pay our license fee for because it certainly isn't for original and groundbreaking television!!

14/02/2012 22:40
avatar

Its nice to watch two period dramas that have no bad language and that are very in-offensive.  I will reserve judgement as to which one I prefer until I watch them.  I watched the original Upstairs Downstairs as a young child and loved it. 

14/02/2012 22:30
avatar
downton abbey is new and fresh, Much better actors,
14/02/2012 19:38
avatar
We shall watch with interest. One thing's for sure - We won't have all of those damned adverts to contend with!
avatar

I am hoping to enjoy them both equally .  Why are we expected to prefer one instead of the other?

 

Great writing and drama . Bring it on .

 

When you consider the total drivel we are expected to sit through ........soaps , reality TV ...... chat shows , game shows .... I am quite determined to enjoy BOTH . And as for that ridiculous poll above ,..... U/D has n't even aired yet . How very biased and unscientific.

14/02/2012 18:37
avatar
Please note: the original Upstairs Downstairs series was produced and transmitted by ITV not BBC.  It ran for five series and was a worldwide success for British TV in the 1970s winning many awards during its time on screen.  Credit where credit is due. 
avatar

Doubtless they will be put on air at the same time - purely to start yet another ratings war !!!! What concerns any thinking person more than the triviality of how many watch what, is the fact that the author of the article really ought to know a conjunction (for their sake - a conjunction such as AND or BUT) joins two phrases, and, should never (i.e. NEVER) be used to start a sentence - let alone a paragraph !!!!!

Whilst here, may I pose this question - ' in view of the plethora of repeat programmes, would it be all right if I pay for this year's TV licence with the same cheque I used last year?'?

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
Scroll upScroll down

latest tv videos

msn tv poll

How do you feel about Anthony Moon leaving EastEnders?

Thanks for being one of the first people to vote. Results will be available soon. Check for results

  1. 69 %
    Glad - he's boring
    2,163 votes
  2.  
    31 %
    Sad - he's great
    978 votes

Total Responses: 3,141
Not scientifically valid. Results are updated every minute.