Talk TV

US version of Only Fools and Horses gets the green light

News and gossip from the world of TV

By Lorna Coops 30/01/2012 18:13
According to reports, US network ABC has given the green light to a pilot of Only Fools and Horses, the classic sitcom by the late John Sullivan.

The American version will be helmed by Steven Cragg (director of the likes of Desperate Housewives and Boston Legal, producer of Doogie Howser, MD) and Brian Bradley (producer of US comedy import, Happy Endings).

First broadcast in the UK back in September, 1981, Only Fools told the story of market trader Derek 'Del Boy' Trotter (David Jason), and his various endeavours to strike it lucky and become a millionaire.

Del Boy's brother Rodney (Nicholas Lyndhurst), and various members of his family and friends (including Granddad, Uncle Albert, Boycie, Trigger, Marlene et al) were also along for the ride.
After an inauspicious start, Only Fools and Horses eventually became the BBC's most popular and best-loved comedy. It contributed memorable moments to TV history (one word: chandelier), popularised slang terms ("cushty!"), and gave us catchphrases we'll never forget ("This time next year we'll be millionaires!").

Americans have remade numerous British shows over the years, but with varying results. Till Death US Do Part and Man About The House were successfully reinvented as All In The Family and Three's Company. More recently, Queer As Folk, Being Human and The Office have also made the cut on the other side of the pond.

However, Prime Suspect, Coupling and Skins (to name a few) were abject disasters. Let's hope that fate doesn't befall the US version of Only Fools and Horses.

What do you think? Will an American version of Only Fools and Horses work? Share your views by leaving a comment.


Follow MSN TV on Twitter

 

Follow the TV editor on Twitter: coops_tv



37Comments
30/01/2012 18:41
avatar
There is only one fools and horses. That is a classic british comedy.The good old yanks would never understand our treasured sense of humour. Leave it only please. Will never evr be as good as the original!!!!!!!.
30/01/2012 19:34
avatar
Lol! if they manage to ruin Del-Boy and Rodney they really are plonkers! I hope they don't actually make this!
avatar

Comedic genius' like these can not (and probably will not) be duplicated.....and especially not by Americans!!!

 Nah, not for me, sorry.

30/01/2012 18:57
avatar
The yanks can't make chocolate so they bought Cadbury's. They need to buy our comedy genius? Good luck to 'em. Won't be a patch on the original, but I will have a look!
avatar
Don't you dare America. Dont you dare destroy our greatest ever sitcom. You destroyed Life on Mars and now Shameless. But only fools and horses is taking the p*ss. I so can not bear the shame of watching something so painful so I am not going to waste my time. Cos lets face it. If it gets commissioned for a series only one will be made.
30/01/2012 19:30
avatar

YOU PLONKER America,if you've had the misfortune of watching SHAMELESS (USA) ya know this wont work.......

30/01/2012 19:46
avatar
there you go again the yanks tryin to make a classic  it wont work the yanks dont have a clue there boring they dont get jokes they dont get ironey  they have a complete diff culture than uk  it wont work its just the yanks robbing our ideas and making money there i  dont think i can name one tv show off the yanks that we have tried to remake that tells you lot  the yank s will just rubbish the memory of a classic  uk tv show  i wont be watch in it it will just sully my mind and memory of the uk one  next they will try and remake dads army
avatar

No, no, no, no..................​...........

 

avatar

You'll Never manage it you americano's This Famous Fabulous Hysterical sitcom with all its Fabulous cast belongs to us Great Great Britain We are the Best and will remain the Best in making the world laugh with our Great British  sense of Humour along with our First class actors such as our one and only Del Boy and Rodney  and  numerous more.

 

Simply the Best and Simply will remain Ours for Us To Boast About

 

 

Martini glass    To all that's Great Britain 

avatar

America dont have a clue about making comedy series and if they attempt this they are going to destroy a classic,   Sorry for any Americans reading this but they just dont get the sarcastic sence of humour that is required to play Del Boy

 

Who the hell would they cast to play the parts???

 

They destroyed Shameless and the Office

30/01/2012 21:51
avatar
 what can i say, poor old john sullivan must be turning in his grave!!!!! A TRUE ENGLISH LEGEND!!!!!!
only fools and horse is a absoluetly classic!! end of!!!! the only thing this US version will have in common will be the name!
avatar
What's wrong with the Americans seeing the real thing? David Jason & Co would go down a treat. Can you imagine anything worse than an American playing Trigger?
30/01/2012 19:12
avatar
Cannot think of any of the British comedy classics transferring all that well on the bib screen or small screen..   Lost In Translation.
30/01/2012 21:51
avatar
if it is not about war  and killing defenceless people the yanks will not be interested
30/01/2012 23:11
avatar
it will fail as there is no guns in it. So who will play del ....sly stallone? look yank we couldn't do friends and you can do only fools and horses so save your money and dont shame your actors
30/01/2012 20:02
avatar
bbc america - do Americans pay to watch bbc service? are we as license payers able to watch this bbc service? its annoying we pay for this poor network to operate its even worse that we have to pay even if we choose not to watch bbc at all. 

now they going to sully david jasons finest performances by letting the yanks play with it 2 wrongs dont make a right and bbc certainly only know go left. wheres our cut of money they getting for selling a British masterpiece? we paid for it we bought it yet we get no say!
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
  • Lorna CooperLorna Cooper

    Nicknamed 'Coops', Lorna is MSN's TV editor. She has too many TV faves to list, but she loves good telly. Read her opinions on the world of TV.

latest tv videos
Vote now

What is the best TV drama of 2013 so far?

Thanks for being one of the first people to vote. Results will be available soon. Check for results

  1.  
    9 %
    The Fall
    1,886 votes
  2.  
    25 %
    Game of Thrones
    5,412 votes
  3.  
    23 %
    Broadchurch
    4,977 votes
  4.  
    2 %
    Mad Men
    341 votes
  5.  
    5 %
    Arrow
    1,126 votes
  6.  
    17 %
    Call The Midwife
    3,559 votes
  7.  
    8 %
    Endeavour
    1,662 votes
  8.  
    3 %
    The Americans
    615 votes
  9.  
    4 %
    The Village
    854 votes
  10.  
    4 %
    Mad Dogs
    805 votes

Total Responses: 21,237
Not scientifically valid. Results are updated every minute.